Moderator : Ashley
Paneler : Lucy, Emily, Isabela, Sopie, Sara
Before the discussion
Lucy (disagree) : Students can't write memo or draw line. Also they can't check their textbook at their home and they can't carry them.
Emily (disagree) : When I was a student, I wrote important part on the my textbook and it&s good for me. So I disagree with the topic.
Isabela (disagree) : Students listen carefully to what teachers saying to make memo, so if they don't have their textbooks, they will not concentrate on their study.
Sophie (agree) : Every year school have to prepare many textbook for students and the cost is so big. If we introduce rental system, we can cut and save money.
Sara (agree) : Preparing textbook for students every year costs a lot. If we introduce rental system, we can use the money that we saved for more high quality tools or textbook.
In the discussion
Ashley : How do you think about cost of textbooks now?
Emily : This cost is important for education of children and in our future.
Sophie : But if we can use the saved money for PC, more confortable class rooms, and so on.
Lucy : What is the main purpose of the system?
Sara (I) : School make students concentrate on study and listen to carefully.
Lucy : The main purpose of both of agree and disagree sides are same, and rental system has some good points. How abot introduce traial period?
Conclusion
We introduce traial period of this system. And if we get good date and we regart rental system as good, we will change the low.
My comment
This discussion was last for our group as panels. My classmates often said that I spoke small voice and they couldn't catch. I tried to care about it in this discussion, though I may often talk little voice when I didn't have confidence in my opinion or the accuracy. In addition to any member should tell their opinion crearly, but it was difficult. Still paneler should make concretely background and people include the audience should listen to carefuly and understand, then take the floor actively, I felt through discussions.
2015年1月18日日曜日
Teachers shouldn't give any homework to students.
Moderator : Rie
Paneler : Anna, Rachel, Kate, Alex
Before the discussion
Anna (agree) : Without homework, students can have time for their study of what they don't understand. They can spend their time effectively.
Rachel (agree) : Free time of students less cause of their homework.
Kate (disagree) : I disagree with the topic of two reasons. First, students don't study willingly at home. Second, I think in order to realize dreams of students, they should do their homework.
Alex (disagree) : Homework helps student what they have learned, so teacher should give homework to students.
In the discussion
Alex : Anna, you said that students can spend their time effectively without their homework. But I don't think so. Children may play game or hang out with their friend after school. Why do you think so?
Anna : Because students can't study enough at their classes. If they have week point in their study, they should study at home. If they don't have to do homework, they can use their time for their study.
Alex : It's important to give homework to level up for students. By doing homework, they can check their level and know that they understand or not. Students need homework for their study.
Rachel : I think it's possible without homework.
Finnian : Please tell me the grades of the students on the topic.
Rie : High school students.
Robert : Are you just recommend or make the rule that teacher can't give homework to their students?
Rie : Just recommendation.
Lucus : Teachers of elementary school and junior high school should teach how to study.
Alex : Yeah, I hope so. If they do so, students will understand how to study.
Anna : Because students can't study enough at their classes. If they have week point in their study, they should study at home. If they don't have to do homework, they can use their time for their study.
Alex : It's important to give homework to level up for students. By doing homework, they can check their level and know that they understand or not. Students need homework for their study.
Rachel : I think it's possible without homework.
Finnian : Please tell me the grades of the students on the topic.
Rie : High school students.
Robert : Are you just recommend or make the rule that teacher can't give homework to their students?
Rie : Just recommendation.
Lucus : Teachers of elementary school and junior high school should teach how to study.
Alex : Yeah, I hope so. If they do so, students will understand how to study.
Conclusion
Teachers must not give homework to high school students.
My comment
I felt that this group need more detail background. Especially, they should defined the grade of study on this topic. Because some panelers thought it as elementary school students, and others did as junior high school or high school. If the definition was obscure, sometimes the content of this discussion for each person. This topic is difficult, though I could think about what is study, so I enjoyed.
I regard study as what for every students, so teacher should teach with adapting students who are not good at studying. Of course high level students can get more high quality homework, if they ask their teacher. Though teacher should not give up on their poor students absolutely.
I felt that this group need more detail background. Especially, they should defined the grade of study on this topic. Because some panelers thought it as elementary school students, and others did as junior high school or high school. If the definition was obscure, sometimes the content of this discussion for each person. This topic is difficult, though I could think about what is study, so I enjoyed.
I regard study as what for every students, so teacher should teach with adapting students who are not good at studying. Of course high level students can get more high quality homework, if they ask their teacher. Though teacher should not give up on their poor students absolutely.
登録:
投稿 (Atom)